Men and Dancing: Why they don’t Mix in the West


While reading African Dance: An Artistic Historical and Philosophical Inquiry, one essay caught my attention called, “Bridges to Humanity.” In it, author Tracy D. Snipe discusses the physical, psychological, and spiritual context of African dance. “There is no art for art’s sake in Africa, because all of life is art in African, including the dance.”

Snipe discusses the aesthetics of dance, the symbolism and mode of communication it wields. In the section about conservation of dance, Snipe pointed out something I found intriguing:

“African dance teaches us priceless lessons about cross-cultural comparisons. For example, the issue of men dancing in Africa has significant cross-cultural overtones. The entire concept of men dancing in traditional African society is seen in a totally different context in comparison with the view of men dancing in the West. The war dances in particular are viewed as virility, strength, and sexual prowess. By contrast, in Western societies men who dance are labeled effeminate or homosexuals merely because they dance.”

I asked my husband, “Why don’t men like to dance?” after reading this.

“I don’t know,” he said, “it just seems gay.”

(Please keep in mind, that my husband is one of the least homophobic straight males I have EVER met in my life and that this was not meant in any derogatory sense. Just that dancing seems stereotypically effeminate.)

So then I read him this passage and asked him what he thought. He said there is probably a lot of truth to that. Men feel inhibited to dance not just out of shyness or awkwardness but because other men will view them as effeminate. This is something I find incredibly sad. Dance is such a powerful way of connecting with our bodies, it’s terrible that men can’t or won’t go there because of social stigmas.

Snipe thinks Christianity and Islam are major culprits to the stamping out of traditional African dance. He also points out that Europeans once had these rich and vibrant traditions we find so fascinating in Africa, but that Christianity killed it. Anything remotely connected to the body was labeled sinful during the Dark Ages/Inquisition period and was punishable by death. It’s a wonder that we were able to preserve any of our old cultures at all.

Perhaps the social stigma of dance as a female art merely stems from the fact that women were the ones who were able to retain some of the pagan traditions of dance.

My husband also pointed out that as much as Western Europe gets blamed for colonizing and destroying ethnic cultures in the world, it’s important to remember that Europe was also colonized and homogenized through the hammer of the Christian Church, especially the Northern European cultures. Christianity is inherently a Greek/Mediterranean culture, that would have seemed completely alien to the Teutonic and Celtic tribes. We may have had these forms of ritualized dance in our distant past, but they have been so thoroughly expunged from European culture as to be completely forgotten. I feel very cheated that I have no idea what my ancestors’ beliefs and rituals were. It becomes very important to me that the places where these things still exist are left alone. All that Christian/Islamic “love” can stop spreading thank you very much.

I asked my husband if we had dances like the African war dance or the Maori Haka, if he thought men might embrace dance more:

and he said yeah because, “that’s fuckin’ cool!”

In essence, what this essay brought to the forefront of my mind is the need for ritual. Western culture and in particular American culture is so devoid of meaning there’s no wonder people are constantly grappling with an existential crisis. And I don’t just mean paying lip service to some church. My biggest gripe with most religions is that they won’t evolve or that they believe all must be just like them in order to be “saved.” Hence, the destruction of millions of organic cultures the world over.

It’s important to create truly meaningful traditions that are relevant to our “tribe” right now. Perhaps then we might perform our daily tasks with purpose, women might take pleasure in their femininity again, and perhaps men might dance ;0)

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Men and Dancing: Why they don’t Mix in the West

  1. Great post! I spent several years living in New Zealand and love watching the traditional Maori dances! The haka always gives me chills. I don't know any guys that would call that "gay"! But I do know plenty of guys that are extremely rigid within their own bodies because of being raised not to express themselves with physical movement…as well as women like me, thanks to my conservative Christian upbringing that forbid dancing of any sort. I can feel the dance within me when I hear music, or drums, or have my feet on the earth, I just don't know how to let it out yet. It feels too foreign. Sure does say something about the far-reaching effects of obliterating entire cultures in the name of one's god. Wonder what the religions of today doing to the health of generations to come?

  2. There are so many things about Western/European/Christian "culture" that are stiff and dehumanizing. It's as if we are brought up to be as confused, afraid, and desensitized to our own energy intentionally so we will always accept the "right way". I love to dance (as you know)and am seeking meaningful rituals to bring into my life and my family… keep sharing! You have more time to read than I do. 🙂

  3. @ Tiara. Gee thanks for sharing. That was really brave. I am glad you recognize the rhythms happening within your own body, you've just got to let them out. Try dancing in a room by yourself. Don't worry about how you "look" just focus on how you "feel." The first time I ever tapped into that energy I cried afterwards, it was so powerful. Real dancing, the spiritual kind, is less about looking cool and more about feeling good. Remember that next time you start to feel inhibited. Good people will catch your mood and it will become contagious when they see you dancing with feeling. Is doesn't matter it you look ridiculous or you're cutting rug like Patrick Swayze, they'll love it ;0)@ Becca. My hope is that religious "acceptance" (because I hate the word tolerance) will open up some more to allow lots of cultures to mix and retain their authenticity, while spreading the "message" of their faith, not their cultural morays. Most of the things that are so negative about these religions are social norms that came from the tribe in which they developed. They have less to do with God and more to do with humans, and that's why they're missing the point. I bet the Creator doesn't care if we celebrate Him/Her/It by kneeling down to pray or leaping for joy as long as we remember divinity. I think it should be less about how and more about why. That's just my opinion of course but if I started my own philosophy, it would be more like that. Hugs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s